Monday, December 27, 2010

As predicted, Rudy Phan posted a bull**** explanation of how TVI Express is Halal

Previously Muslim Council of Aceh, Indonesia declared a fatwa (Islamic edict) that TVI Express is a money game (i.e. scam) and thus is haram (unclean).

Rudy Phan, of course, takes the opposite position, that TVI Express is 100% halal. Why?

The only reason he could give was "they don't understand us", one of the 13 different false arguments used ty TVI Express scammers. Basically, Rudy Phan's conclusion is that the council had been influenced by opponents of TVI Express (such as this blog) or people who don't really understand TVI Express. Quote from his article (through Google translate)
I have a hypothesis that the MPU Aceh conclusion came from the wrong source of TVI Express, resulting in incorrect conclusions.

So who has correct conclusions about TVI Express? Rudy Phan and his upline (in New York), of course.

Who are you to declare things 100% halal? Are you even Muslim, Rudy? I know I'm not.

And where's evidence that supports your hypothesis? Nothing! You have NOTHING!

Hypothesis without evidence is merely an opinion. And as the old sayings go, opinions are like ***holes, everybody's got one.

The Muslim Council of Aceh gave a carefully reasoned argument on why things are so. Rudy Phan's only rebuttal: "they don't understand us". It's basically a carefully worded personal attack, i.e. ad hominem.

Sounds like it's written for himself, as a part of the "denial" phase of grief.


Enhanced by Zemanta

No comments: